Protecting yourself
The crack was there when you arrived. Can you prove it?
This is a different problem from extra work, and it costs contractors just as much. A cracked tile, a scuffed floor, a hairline in the drywall near where you were working. The customer notices it after you leave, connects it to the only thing that changed that day, and sends a message. They are not lying. They genuinely never noticed it before. And unless you have a photograph, you are arguing about a memory neither of you actually has.
Direct answer
Photograph the work area before you touch anything, every job, as a two-minute habit. Wide shots of the room, then closer shots of anything already damaged. The photos cost you nothing on the ninety-nine jobs where nobody complains, and settle the hundredth completely.
01Workflow
The arrival routine
- 1
Before tools come out, take three or four wide shots of the work area.
- 2
Take close-ups of anything already chipped, cracked, stained, or loose.
- 3
Include something that dates the photo if your phone does not stamp it visibly.
- 4
Mention out loud anything significant you noticed, so it is not a surprise later.
- 5
File the photos with the job the same day, not in a camera roll you will never search.
02Practical notes
What matters in the field.
The accusation is almost never dishonest.
People do not inventory their own homes. A chip in the corner of a tile has been there for two years and gone unseen, and then a stranger works in that room and it becomes visible. Understanding that this is perception rather than a scam changes how you respond - and a photo lets you resolve it without either of you having to be the liar.
Wide shots matter more than close-ups.
A close photo of a crack proves the crack existed. A wide shot proves where it was and what the room looked like when you arrived, which is what actually answers the question. Take both, but never skip the wide ones - they are the context that makes the detail meaningful.
Mention it at the time, not just in the file.
Pointing something out on arrival - 'just so you know, there's already a chip on this one here' - does two jobs at once. It records the condition and it establishes you as someone who notices and says things. Contractors who do this report the accusation almost never comes, because the customer has already been told.
Same habit, different use, as the approval photos.
Contractors who already photograph discovered problems for change orders are most of the way there. It is the same phone, the same file, the same thirty seconds. The only change is doing it on arrival by default instead of only when you find something worth billing for.
If you are accused and you have nothing, respond carefully.
Do not concede and do not dismiss it. Ask when they first noticed, go look if you can, and say honestly what you know: where you worked, what you touched, what you did not. Offering a small goodwill repair without accepting blame is a common resolution, but decide that on the value of the relationship rather than under pressure in the moment.
03Checklist
The two-minute arrival habit
Wide shots of the work area before anything is moved
Close-ups of existing damage, chips, cracks, and stains
A visible date, or a phone that stamps it
Anything significant mentioned to the customer out loud
Photos filed with the job the same day
The habit applied to every job, not only the ones that feel risky
Example
How it plays out
On arrival: 'Before I start - there's already a chip on this tile by the door and the trim's loose over here. Just flagging it so we both know.'
Two weeks later: 'Hi - I've got photos from the morning I arrived, and that chip is in them. Happy to send them over.'
If it is genuinely yours: 'That one's mine, I'll take care of it. I'll be back Thursday.'
04FAQ
Common questions.
Isn't photographing everything a bit paranoid?
It reads as thorough rather than suspicious if you say why: documenting the starting condition is normal practice on any job where you are working in someone's finished space. Two minutes on arrival costs less than one disputed repair.
How long should I keep the photos?
At least as long as you would expect a complaint to surface, which for most residential work is months rather than days. Keeping them attached to the job record rather than in a camera roll is what makes retrieval possible at all.
What if the damage really was mine?
Say so quickly and fix it. Contractors who own a mistake immediately usually keep the customer. The photos are not there to help you deny things - they are there so that the conversation is about what actually happened rather than about who is more convincing.
See what the approval record looks like.
Open the sample PDF first, then download SiteTicket AI if this is close to how you handle added work, customer approval, and invoice backup.
Related guides
Change order with signature: what to capture before extra work starts.
When a contractor needs a signed change order, what to include, when to collect the signature, and how to keep a clean approval record.
Extra work approval text: wording to send before continuing.
Copy-ready wording contractors can send when a customer asks for extra work while the job is already underway.
Contractor change order template for small extra work.
A practical contractor change order template for extra work, added cost, customer approval, and invoice handoff.